A $63M Loss: The Critical Role of Due Diligence & Background Checks in Business Partnerships

Could a background check have stopped the $63 million Nightingale fraud? Probably not on its own. What a check on Nightingale Properties and its CEO, Elie Schwartz, would have shown before the CrowdStreet raise was a 2021 lawsuit over a defaulted $6 million loan, the kind of finding that should prompt harder questions before investors’ money moves. Schwartz later pleaded guilty to wire fraud and in May 2025 was sentenced to 87 months in federal prison and ordered to pay more than $45 million in restitution.
CrowdStreet is a real estate investment platform that pools money from individual investors to fund commercial property deals. In 2022, Nightingale Properties used it to raise money for two projects: an office complex in Atlanta and a mixed-use building in Miami Beach.
According to the Justice Department, Schwartz raised about $62.8 million from hundreds of investors and told them their money would sit in segregated accounts and go only to those two properties. Instead, he moved substantially all of it into his personal bank and brokerage accounts and into unrelated real estate businesses he controlled. Neither deal closed, and in July 2023 the two entities he formed to receive the money filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
Schwartz pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud in February 2025. In May 2025, a federal judge in the Northern District of Georgia sentenced him to 87 months in prison and ordered him to pay more than $45 million in restitution (United States v. Schwartz, No. 1:24-cr-371).
CrowdStreet says it vets the sponsors on its platform. Investors who lost money have since argued in arbitration and in court that it didn’t vet Nightingale closely enough, and that their money should not have been released before the deals closed.
Before the CrowdStreet raise, Elie Schwartz was named as a defendant in a 2021 lawsuit filed by Nakash Bellevue LLC (New York County Supreme Court, Index No. 655309/2021).
In the complaint filed on 09/02/2021, Nakash Bellevue LLC claims the defendant failed to pay back a $6,000,000 loan pursuant to a valid promissory note. Nakash Bellevue indicates the defendant is in default of the loan and that at the time of the filing of the lawsuit, the defendant owed an outstanding $4,981,500.01. The parties settled the case in August 2022, a few months after the CrowdStreet fundraising began.
So, not only could CrowdStreet have done more effective due diligence before working with Nightingale Properties, but so too could have the investors who gave their money to the real estate crowdfunding platform.
For example, if Business Screen had been hired to conduct a check on Nightingale Properties and Elie Schwartz, red flags would have alerted the client of a previous civil litigation against the CEO and the negative news article referencing one of the companies’ managed properties.
It’s worth noting that these due diligence red flags wouldn’t have predicted the $63 million fraud, but they could have raised some questions about what was occurring at their firm before the news of this incident came out.
The lesson is less about any single record than about who gets screened. The entities raising the money were new; the person behind them had the history. That’s why a business background check should cover the principals too, not just the company on paper.
This also applies to businesses looking for partnerships or investments from other companies—be confident a partner is legitimate and trustworthy with robust investor screening before entering into any financial agreements.
For the same lesson from the venture side, see how to check a founder before the investment committee.
Ultimately, due diligence can be one of the most powerful ways to protect yourself from fraudulent or irresponsible business practices.
It comes with all kinds of benefits, including:
1. Risk mitigation
Conducting due diligence and background checks help identify potential risks associated with a company, such as:
Understanding these risks allows businesses to make informed decisions and avoid partnering with unreliable or harmful entities.
In the case of Nightingale Properties, for example, someone who does their due diligence ahead of time would have seen the lawsuit against its CEO, which might sway whether they choose to work with Nightingale or not, knowing what they know.
2. Financial security
By verifying a company’s financial status, including its credit history and payment behavior, businesses safeguard themselves from entering into agreements with financially unstable partners. This can help make sure payment obligations will be fulfilled, reducing the risk of financial losses.
Learn how to request a business credit check here.
3. Legal and financial history
A thorough background check should include:
In this case, a quick Google search would reveal the negative news reports about Nightingale Properties and its CEO, one of the checks covered in our guide on how to vet a company before you do business with it.
4. Reputation preservation
It’s no surprise that partnerships with controversial companies can lead to damage to your reputation, and ultimately lost customers.
By doing a thorough background check, businesses know they are aligning themselves with reputable organizations that share similar values and ethical standards.
For investors and platforms backing real estate deals, the sponsor and its principals are the first thing to screen, ahead of the property itself. A prior lawsuit doesn’t prove fraud, and a clean report doesn’t rule it out, but a finding like the Nakash case is the moment to ask where the money will sit and who controls it.
Our commercial real estate due diligence guide covers who to vet on a deal and what to search on each.